The Scarlet Google Search: the use of digital data as evidence in criminal conduct for abortions
We confess our secrets to Google. We tell Google the things that we can’t bring ourselves to say to our friends and family. We hope someone has asked the same question on the Internet, we hope other people have answered them. We hope we are not alone in our problems; we hope someone can helpus.
Carla Foster wrote desperate questions into Google about how to obtain a pregnancy termination. She whispered her secrets to Google and her questions were turned into evidence that was used to convict her to 28 months in jail.
Data privacy, the law, and your sensitive information
The current infrastructure of the internet was not constructedto protect women and other minoritised groups. Our sensitive data is likely to be shared to the highest third-party bidder or prosecutor, whoever comes first.
For example, a recent report determined that Facebook had sold the private data of users to anti-abortion organisations. As a result, Facebook users that had sought information on abortion were said to receive targeted advertisements to stop pregnant people from pursuing pregnancy terminations.
Big Tech companies have also refused to officially commenton whether they will provide data to law enforcement agencies that seek data to prosecute abortion.
It was once sacrosanct that our sensitive health information was private, now it is now a product to commodify or prosecute us. The United Nations Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights, Philip Alston, surmisedthis situation by saying, “citizens [have] become ever more visible to their governments, but not the other way around.”
Examples of private data being used to prosecute abortion
Latice Fisher was prosecuted for an abortion in the United States. She willingly surrendered her phone to police and her Google searches determined that she sought to procure an abortion. As her spokesperson said,
“Lots of people Google about abortion and then choose to carry out their pregnancies… Thought crimes are not the thing. You’re not supposed to be able to be indicted on a charge of what you thought about.”
Carla Foster’s was not the first case wherein which private data, and Google searches, have been used to prosecute an individual for an abortion. Globally, seemingly private data is used in the prosecution of individuals that have had an abortion, or aided someone having an abortion:
• A mother and her (fourteen-year-old) daughter in the United States were prosecuted for illegally obtaining an abortion for the teenager, after Facebook provided the daughter’s private messages to prosecutors.
• In Poland, Justyna Wydrzyńska assisted a woman to procure drugs for an abortion, her computers (along with the computers of her children) were seized as evidence.
• In Iran, every lab-based pregnancy test is provided to a centralised system that is used to track pregnancies and determine whether an individual has procured an illegalabortion.
Ultimately, as a recent study by Maryam Mehrnezhad and Teresa Almeida states “modern technologies may… exacerbate multi-layered harms and risks such as discrimination, bias in algorithms and datasets, and gender-based harassment and violence”. In the case of theprosecution of abortion, modern technologies have been weaponised to become evidence for prosecutors to interrogate a guilty mind.
Steps to protect your sensitive data
The lack of protection on our private data is currently not being mitigated by legislators or tech companies. However, there are steps that an individual can make their personal investigation on abortions more private.
As the Digital Defense Fund suggests:
• Turn off your location on your phone;
• Use search engines that does not collect data on your searches;
• Use Firefox focus; and,
• Disable your mobile ad ID.
Manna Mostaghim is a PhD Candidate in the Health Policy Department at the LSE. Her PhD thesis is on the provision of publicly subsidised IVF for women with a high BMI in the U.K.
For regular updates and action on abortion rights and campaigning, sign up to our weekly round up newsletter.